If you’re like many people, you’ve spent years collecting photos and videos of your family’s best moments—like graduations, weddings, and everyday joys.

But as time goes on, these memories can fade, VHS tapes can wear out, and photos might start to look old or even disappear. There’s always the worry that an accident could erase them forever.

That’s why more and more folks are turning to digital converters and online services for help. Converting your precious memories into digital formats not only protects them from decay and damage but also ensures they can be enjoyed by future generations.

To help you choose the right option, we’ve put together a list of the best services available today. We looked at things like quality, reputation, cost, security, and how well they work. Our research led us to recommend these top 5 choices that will keep your cherished memories safe for years to come.

Here’s a quick look at the top 5 options for converting your old tapes to digital format. iMemories stands out as our top choice for its ease of use and affordability, available worldwide.

  1. iMemories (Easiest Option)
  2. Costco Photo Center (Best Local Choice)
  3. ClearClick Digital Converter (Great for Doing It Yourself)
  4. Elgato Video Capture
  5. CVS Photo Center

Why iMemories is Our Top Pick for Converting Old Tapes to Digital

When it comes to converting old tapes to digital, iMemories has emerged as our top choice, backed by research from Times-Standard.com and DailyDemocrat. Here’s why iMemories stands out compared to its competitors:

  1. Handles Various Formats: iMemories excels at converting Video-8 and a wide range of other video formats to digital, making it versatile for different types of media.
  2. Speed and Convenience: Customers appreciate iMemories for its quick service, especially when using their app for digital transfers. This convenience is faster compared to other services like Legacybox and ScanCafe.
  3. Experience Matters: With 18 years in the industry, iMemories has built a strong reputation for reliability, although Capture has been around longer.
  4. Customer Satisfaction: According to SiteJabber, iMemories enjoys a high rating of 4.74 stars out of 5 from over 13,000 reviews. While most customers praise their service quality, some have noted concerns about pricing, service speed, and additional charges for features such as using the app and obtaining USB copies.
  5. Considerations: While iMemories offers competitive pricing overall, the cost for scanning photos and negatives can be higher. They do not directly integrate with Google Photos or Drive, and their satisfaction guarantee may not be as straightforward as some competitors.

In summary, iMemories is our top recommendation for its ability to handle diverse media formats, user-friendly app for faster transfers, and generally positive customer feedback, making it a trusted choice for preserving your precious memories digitally.

Jpost.com has picked iMemories as their top choice for converting old tapes online, highlighting its expertise in transforming VHS tapes into digital formats.

Best Digital Converters on Amazon

Elgato Video Capture is our top pick for turning old VHS tapes, camcorder recordings, and other analog videos into digital files. This easy-to-use device works with Mac, PC, and iPad. Its simple software guides you through each step of the process, capturing video in a format that works with iPad, iMovie, Windows Live Movie Maker, and YouTube.

With a solid rating of 4.4 out of 5 stars from over 10,000 reviews worldwide, customers love Elgato Video Capture for its straightforward setup and reliable performance in transferring old videos to digital. However, some users have mixed opinions about audio and picture quality, as well as occasional issues with the software.

Overall, Elgato Video Capture offers a convenient solution for digitizing analog videos, providing reliable performance and compatibility with various devices and software platforms.


  • Easy Conversion: Simplifies the process of digitizing old tapes and analog videos.
  • Works Everywhere: Compatible with Mac, PC, and iPad, making it versatile.
  • Simple Software: Guides you through each step, ensuring an easy digitization process.
  • User-Friendly: Easy for everyone to use.


  • Software Issues: Some users find the software for previewing and converting videos less than perfect.
  • Compatibility Challenges: Some users struggle with setup on Windows 11.
  • Mixed Reviews: While setup is straightforward, some users report varied results in video quality.

Best Local Choice for Converting Old Tapes

Costco Photo Center is a great option for converting your old VHS tapes and other analog formats to digital. Here’s why:


  1. Convenience: You can drop off your tapes at any Costco store, saving you from shipping hassles.
  2. Quality Service: Costco ensures professional handling and high-quality digitization.
  3. Affordable: Prices are competitive compared to online services.
  4. Handles Various Formats: They can digitize VHS tapes, camcorder tapes, and more.


  1. Membership Required: You need to be a Costco member to use their services.
  2. Turnaround Time: It may take longer during busy times at the store.
  3. In-Person Drop-Off: You have to visit a Costco store to drop off your tapes.

Costco Photo Center is a convenient and reliable choice if you prefer local service for digitizing your old tapes. It’s perfect if you’re already a Costco member and want hands-on assistance with preserving your memories digitally.


In conclusion, when you’re looking to convert VHS tapes to digital format, you have two main options: local services like Costco Photo Center and online services like iMemories.

Local options such as Costco Photo Center offer convenience because you can drop off your tapes in person at a nearby store. This can be great if you prefer face-to-face service and want your tapes handled locally.

On the other hand, online services like iMemories provide flexibility. You can securely send your tapes to be digitized remotely, which is convenient if you prefer to manage everything online and need access to a broader range of digitization options beyond just VHS.

Choosing between these options depends on factors like your preference for in-person interaction, ease of use, and specific needs such as format compatibility and turnaround time. Whether you go with a local drop-off at Costco or opt for the flexibility of iMemories, both ensure your VHS memories are converted to digital format for safekeeping and future enjoyment.

Categorized in: